Who Owns Your Decline Rate?
Fraud, engineering and finance each see a piece of the problem. Nobody's measured on the sales you didn't make.
This week we looked at three reasons good transactions get declined. Fraud rules that turn away good buyers. Issuer declines that were recoverable. Cross-border transactions that fail because of where they're processed.
Different causes, different fixes. But at most companies I've worked with, they share one root problem: nobody owns the decline rate.
Every team sees a piece
Fraud owns the rules
The fraud team's job is to stop bad transactions, and that's usually how they're measured: chargebacks, fraud losses, dispute ratios. The good customers their rules turn away rarely show up on anyone's scorecard. So the rules drift tighter, and nobody pushes back.
Engineering owns the integration
For engineering, a payment request that goes out and gets a response back is a working integration. A decline is a valid response. Unless someone asks them to, they have no reason to look at which data fields are missing, how retries are handled, or which processor a transaction is routed through.
Finance sees the revenue
Finance is the team that feels the result, but it's the hardest place to see it. Declines don't show up as a loss on the P&L. They show up as sales that never happened, and a sale that never happened doesn't appear on any report.
Each team is doing its job. The money still walks out the door.
The fix is an owner, not a tool
There's no shortage of tools that promise better approval rates. Most of them only help if someone is already watching the number and has the authority to act on it. Start there.
Give one person ownership of your approval rate, and have them review it every month, broken out by:
Decline reason (fraud rule, issuer response, technical error)
Card country and currency
Processor or acquiring route
Payment method and channel
Then give that person the authority to get fraud, engineering, and your payment provider in the same room when the numbers move. Most decline problems aren't solved by one team. They sit between teams, and that's where they stay until someone is accountable for them.
The Takeaway
Heading into peak season, recovering good transactions you're already turning away is the cheapest revenue you'll find all year. But it only happens if someone is measured on it. If nobody's measured on the sales you didn't make, nobody's going to go get them back.
Comments